Cherry Supremes made in Richmond since 1980
Shari Alvey learned to make candy from her Grandma Winget, and for a while only family and friends got any. Then people started asking to buy it. In 1980 Shari and her husband Cless opened Alvey's Chocolates in Richmond, up the north end of Cache Valley, with exactly four candy bars. All four are still on the menu, starting with the Cherry Supreme.
The Cherry Supreme is a maraschino cherry inside a cherry fondant center, wrapped in milk chocolate and chopped peanuts. The Double Dip Mint is a green mint fondant patty under a layer of milk and dark chocolate. Caramel Nut and Peanut Supreme rounded out the original lineup. Each chocolate gets a hand mark on top, the old candy shop code that tells you which center you are about to bite into. A seven piece pack of Cherry Supremes is $19.04 on the website, a fair price for a candy bar the shop has made since 1980.
In March 2006 Janette and Brent Kelly bought the business. Janette already knew the place, because she had worked at the store before she owned it. She still uses Grandma Winget's recipes, with only small changes, she told Cache Valley Daily in 2020. "I like making chocolates because they make people smile," she said. Hard to argue with that job description.
The ingredients stay close to home. Kelly buys the sugar at local grocery stores, and the butter and cream come from local dairies, which in Cache Valley is a short drive. She counted about 200 products in 2020, from almond coated English toffee to sea salt caramels. She added a sugar free line too.
Most of the money, though, is not made at the counter. "Most of our business is wholesale," Kelly said. Alvey's sells to candy shops across the West, eight other states by Cache Valley Daily's count in 2020 and ten by the company's own. That year she said a new deal had put them in Salt Lake City International Airport as well. So there is a decent chance you have eaten one without knowing whose kitchen it came from.
One honest note. The factory on 300 South in Richmond has only a small outlet, where the seconds are sold, and Kelly suggests calling before you drop by. A Cherry Supreme with a crooked hand mark tastes the same, and it costs less.
Forty-six years on, the four candy bars Shari Alvey started with are still made on 300 South in Richmond.
Researched and written by Beehive Made. Last checked .
Work at Alvey's Chocolates? Confirm this page or send a fix. Get the badge for your site too.
Some Alvey's chocolates end up boxed and sold under another company's name, owner Janette Kelly told Cache Valley Daily in 2020.
The Monday email
What Utah brands launched this week, every Monday. Sign up and the State of Utah Brands report is yours as a thank-you.















