Baby moccasins still sewn to order in Lindon
To raise $200 for her first proper batch of leather, Susan Petersen spent a summer knocking the glass out of old windows and selling the metal frames for scrap. It was the start of Freshly Picked. In 2009 she was 21 and living in a small Salt Lake City apartment while her husband studied at the University of Utah. Her son Gus had chubby feet that no store-bought shoe would stay on.
So she made him a pair. The first moccasins came from leather scraps she bought at a yard sale for $1, sewn at her kitchen table. She blogged about them and other parents asked for pairs. The Etsy shop where she had been selling baby blankets turned into a moccasin shop. The first pairs sold for $20. Entrepreneur later called that price foolishly inexpensive, since she had not yet worked out what leather costs.
In January 2014 she went on Shark Tank asking for $150,000 for 10 percent. Kevin O'Leary offered half the money. Daymond John offered all of it for 25 percent, and she took his deal on air. Then, she told Entrepreneur, John renegotiated after the taping and the deal fell apart. "It looked like we won and at the same time I didn't have to give up any piece of my company," she said. That is the best way I have heard to lose a deal.
The exposure did the work anyway. Entrepreneur reported in 2015 that sales had grown from $120,000 to $5.4 million in three years. Salt Lake Magazine wrote that she had sewn at that table until 2013. By 2019 the shoes were in Nordstrom and Macy's, while about 70 percent of sales still came through the brand's own website. "I'm very scrappy and I'm really stubborn," she told the magazine.
The shoes are still made here. The company's blog says every baby shoe is made to order by hand in Utah, and a 2023 tour of its Lindon production floor says the team can turn out a shoe in about five minutes and aims to make each order the day it comes in. The color names give the address away: a Zion moccasin, a Red Rocks Mary Jane, a Salt Flats shearling and a Uinta knotted bow.
One honest note. The made in Utah promise covers the baby shoes and some small leather goods, and the diaper bags that now fill much of the catalog are not on that list. Ownership has changed too. Seidler Equity Partners, a private equity firm in Marina del Rey, California, listed Freshly Picked as an active portfolio company based in Lindon as recently as May 2026.
The first pair came off a kitchen table in Salt Lake City with $1 of leather. The newest are sewn in Lindon, ideally the same day they are ordered, which is faster than most of us can get a toddler into shoes.
Researched and written by Beehive Made. Last checked .
Work at Freshly Picked? Confirm this page or send a fix. Get the badge for your site too.
Kourtney Kardashian found Freshly Picked moccasins on a Parenting magazine cover shoot with her son Mason, then went and bought a pair herself.
The Monday email
What Utah brands launched this week, every Monday. Sign up and the State of Utah Brands report is yours as a thank-you.













